My overall thoughts of the novel are very high. I enjoyed the book the entire way through and thought that it was a good contrast to Twain. I was very happy for Tati that he was able to make money to take care of himself and his daughter. I had the feeling that he and mother would get married because of how their situations were presented.
I definitely sympathized with Coalhouse in the end. I felt that he had tried to go through the legal system to get the justice that he deserved but that it was corrupt and would not help him. I still do feel that his actions were a bit too intense and that killing the innocent people was wrong, but I could see why he did what he did. I felt bad reading it because he felt like there was nothing else he could do to get justice and he resulted to at the time what he felt was right but later realized it was not.
Doctorow does foreshadowing throughout the novel to hint to the reader how the book is going to end, in war, once in the beginning with the little boy warning Houdini about the duke and again later in the novel toward the end. I did not feel that this war was anything like the war at the end of twain’s book. This war I felt was more of a balance from the benefits of technology to the consequences of having such power available, where as in Twain’s piece I felt that technology had a negative connotation and was over all a drawdown to society.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
I agree with you that the war that ended both the Doctorow and Twain books were very different. Twain seems to show that technology is a bad thing overall for civilization whereas Doctorow seems to suggest that overall it seems to help people (i.e. Tateh). Maybe that would be a good thing to contrast for a paper :)
Kelli
Post a Comment